The Potlatch Club

The Verdict: Barefoot Glamour, Restored.

If you are looking for a sprawling lobby, 24-hour room service, and a thousand lounge chairs, The Potlatch Club is not for you. But if you want to walk 12 acres of pink sand and feel like you’re staying at a wealthy friend's private estate, this is the most important "selection" on Eleuthera right now.

After decades of being a "hidden ruin" where Paul McCartney once hid from the world, it has been meticulously restored. It’s 1960s Bahamas glam meets modern sustainability.

SelectedStay Insider Tip: Request an Ocean View Cottage. You get the same sunrise views as the beachfront units but with much better privacy from the beach walking path.

Why We Selected This Stay

• The History: This isn't a "new" hotel; it’s a legend reborn. You are walking the same paths as Greta Garbo.
• The Scale: With only 11 keys, the staff knows your name (and your drink order) by noon on day one.
• The "Pink Sand" Access: You are positioned on one of the quietest stretches of beach in the Bahamas. No jet skis, no crowds—just the Atlantic.

The Details (What You Need to Know)

• The Food: The Fig Tree restaurant is the heart of the property. The menu is "Island-Chic", expect fresh-caught grouper with organic greens grown on-site.
• The Vibe: Best for couples, writers, and "burnt-out" travelers needing a digital detox.
• The Logistics: A 5-night minimum stay is standard here, reflecting the slow-paced soul of the island.

Unlock SelectedStay Privileges

When you book The Potlatch Club through our direct partner link, you don't just get the best available rate—you get the "Selected" treatment:

• $100 Resort Credit (Valid for dining or spa treatments)
• Priority Early Check-In (Subject to availability)
• Direct Communication: We connect you directly to the hotel's on-site team to ensure your arrival is seamless.